My reading life can be divided into two parts: before my reading list, and after. Prior to 1996, I didn’t keep a list of what I read. But beginning in 1996, perhaps after seeing a list by Eric W. Leuliette sometime in late 1995, I decided to start my own. I started it with the goal of reading a book a week, or 52 books each year. It wasn’t until 2013 or so that I actually hit my goal, but my list has continued, capturing nearly 30 years of my reading.
Rules for My List
- To get on the list, I have to finish the book.
- Each finished book gets a number.
- If I re-read a book and finish it, it gets on the list again with another number.
- Format does not matter. Finishing matters.
How Books Are Rated
I don’t give books stars. When I finish a book I answer up to three questions, and I can skip any of them:
- Pull: how it held me while I was reading. I couldn’t stop, I kept going, I had to push, or I put it down.
- Afterglow: what it left behind. I didn’t want it to end and will read it again, I’m glad I read it, it was fine, or I wish I hadn’t.
- Standing: where it sits among books. Among the best I’ve read, better than most, about typical, or weaker than most.
The answers give the book one of five words, its band:
- Keeper: among the best I’ve read, and one I’ll read again.
- Strong: among the best I’ve read, or one I’ll read again; or any two of these: better than most, glad I read it, couldn’t stop.
- Fine: anything else I answered.
- Missed: weaker than most, or I wish I hadn’t read it.
- Dropped: I put it down.
When the answers point two ways, the band is the first of these that fits: dropped, keeper, missed, strong, fine. A book I put down is dropped however much I admired it.
The band is shown on each book’s own page, under Rating; the list itself doesn’t show it. Books I read before I began rating this way have no band unless I’ve gone back to them. If I change my mind about a book, I rate it again, and its page shows the latest band.
Frequently-Asked Questions
How do you manage to read so much?
My default “idle” is reading. If I am not doing anything else, I’ve always got a book in my hand, or an audiobook on my phone. I frequently read while waiting to do something else, like see the doctor or standing in line.
Audiobook have helped as well. I can listen to an audiobook while working out, commuting, doing chores around the house. I started listening to audiobooks in 2013 and have steadily increased my listening speed to 1.75x today (occasionally 2x depending on the narrator).
Admittedly, I don’t watch much television. I don’t go to the movies often. I’ve mostly given up on social media. I frequently fill that time with reading as well.
But is listening to audiobooks really reading?
Is reading bumps on a page with your fingers reading? Of course it is! I’m simply using another sense to absorb the text.
Do you remember everything you read?
No. Which is why I take notes. Even when listening to audiobooks, I’ll frequently have the paper edition as well so that I can scribble notes in the margins. I even have Shortcuts setup that allow me to capture notes if I am out walking.
Oddly, I can usually remember exactly where I was when I read a book. And I have a Composition Notebook in which I jot down everything I’ve read and often scribble little biographical notes in the margins.

How do you choose what to read next?
I rely heavily on what I the butterfly effect of reading.
Friend and colleagues frequently suggest books, and I thank them graciously, but rarely commit to a recommended title because of how the butterfly effect of reading works. In one instance, a friend recommended Edward O. Wilson’s Consilience to me and it took me about 20 years before I finally read it.
If I find myself struggling to decide what to read next, I do have some sources of inspiration that I return to:
- Modern Library 100 Best Nonfiction
- Modern Library 100 Best Novels
- Sports Illustrated Top 100 Books
- 1,000 Books to Read Before You Die by James Mustich
Do you belong to a book club?
I am a member of the Iliterati, a private bookclub made up of incredibly smart and talented friends, including my wife and even my youngest daughter from time-to-time. We meet monthly and since I generally read 9-10 books in a month, I try to reserve one of those for the bookclub.
Do you read more than one book at a time?
Yes, but not at the same time. Typically, I’m listening to an audiobook. Before bed, or when I go out into the world, I’ll frequently take a paper book with me that I am also reading. I take perverse pleasure in being the only person in a large waiting room not reading off a screen.
Have you read (fill-in-the-blank)?
- Navigate to the my reading list.
- Press ⌘-F (CTRL-F on Windows) and start typing the title.
- Have I read it?
What is your desert island book?
WIll and Ariel Durant’s 11-volume Story of Civilization.
Updated on August 30, 2025.