
I’ve been working my way through The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume I and early this morning, I read Frederick Brown’s 1944 story, “Arena11 Astounding, June 1944.” In the story, humans and an alien civilization known as the Outsiders are about to do battle at the edge of the solar system, when one member of each civilization is plucked from the battle into some kind of other world, a world that resembles the inside of a snow globe, writ large. A superior alien intelligence tells the two representatives that they must fight to the death. Whoever loses not only dies, but their entire civilization will be wiped out.
The story is probably notable for its pacing and puzzles, but also for doing a decent job at presenting the incomprehensibility of an alien life form when presented with one. In the end Our Hero, Carson22 In an earlier version of this post, I said “Tommy Dort.” I was in the middle of reading Murray Leinster’s “First Contact” and go the characters mixed up in my head., kills the alien, and is restored to his ship to find that the threatening fleet of the Outsiders has been completely wiped out. What the story doesn’t seem to touch on at all is the moral implication of wiping an entire civilization from the universe, a kind of Trolley Problem on a cosmic scale.
But when I skim through my contemporaneous notes for the story, what jumps out at me more than anything is this line that I scribbled as I read:
seems very similar to the ST:TNG33 Star Trek: The Next Generation for those not familiar with the jargon. ep. “The Last Outpost”
Now, we all know that I read a lot. I can’t possibly remember everything I read, so I try to take some notes. But even there, the volume of notes is such that I can’t even remember my notes. Where the magic lives, or so it seems to me, is that somehow, through all of this reading, and through all of this note-taking, connections form in my brain. Connections like the observation above. As I read more of “Arena” there was dawning familiarity that I couldn’t quite place, until, suddenly, it was there, like a word on the tip of your tongue that finally emerges in the shower.
Despite my reading experience, I still question my intuition now and then. Discussing books and reading is my favorite subject and I do it enthusiastically and with a great deal of authority, but the authority comes from the enthusiasm. I’m not always convinced that others will buy my sometimes odd or lopsided interpretations. So it is nice, once in a while, to see these flashes of insight confirmed.
When I finished the story I headed over to the Wikipedia page for ““The Last Outpost”” and there, discovered that at least one reviewer complained that it seemed to be a rip-off of an earlier Original Series episode title—wait for it—“Arena.” Interesting.
My experience with Star Trek is somewhat limited. I’ve watched much, but not all of ST:TNG and I’ve seen some of TOS44 The Original Series.. Most of my experience comes from the movies. I could not, therefore, conjure a memory of the TOS episode “Arena” so I followed the Wikipedia rabbit hole to the entry for the original series episode of “Arena.” And there, in the opening paragraph of the entry, I saw the following:
“Arena” is the 18th episode of the first season of the American science fiction television series Star Trek. Written by Gene L. Coon (based on a 1944 short story of the same name by Fredric Brown55 Bold text is mine.) and directed by Joseph Pevney, the episode was first broadcast on January 19, 1967.
Connection made! Intuition confirmed! I don’t know why, exactly, but this kind of thing delights me. It provides the same good feeling that getting an unexpectedly good grade on a test used to give me. It says to me, trust your intuition when it comes to these types of things, you know what you’re talking about. Fortunately, it doesn’t happen very often. If it did, I imagine, I’d be unbearable.
- Astounding, June 1944 ↩︎
- In an earlier version of this post, I said “Tommy Dort.” I was in the middle of reading Murray Leinster’s “First Contact” and go the characters mixed up in my head. ↩︎
- Star Trek: The Next Generation for those not familiar with the jargon. ↩︎
- The Original Series. ↩︎
- Bold text is mine. ↩︎
Comments